In Memoriam (2023)

Historical Note for In Memoriam

The Preshutian: These were entirely based on the Marlborough College newspaper from 1913-1919. I tried to get across the atmosphere of the paper, but I also lifted directly in places.

….He first had a hip and one leg shot away, and still managed to fire off a round or two more, until the other leg was taken off just above the knee. The doctor who told me about it afterwards said that all he asked for was heaps of morphia, so that the men should not hear him screaming, and that he might be taken quickly to the rear. The whole story is that ‘Brad’ died as one felt he would do.

Harold Roseveare’s In Memoriam, from the November 1914 edition:

Marlborough has suffered many blows since the outbreak of the war, but perhaps the hardest is the news of the death of one who left us only at the close of last term, who but two months before had been an essential part of the College….In all our sorrow, we cannot but envy him. All too short though it was, his life, if any can, can truthfully be said to have touched perfection… A happier boy one cannot imagine — happier still in realising his ambition, in dying as he did a true soldier’s death.

He came past me with a very cheerful face, and laughing, under a very hearty cross-fire from machine guns, and sang out to me, ‘Shall I push on?’ and I answered, ‘Go on, laddie, as hard as you can.’ Poor lad, I did not see him again, but heard he was shot in the head, but he would not let anyone stay with him. He was such a good boy, always cheerful and always ready to do anything that was wanted. He was very popular with everyone—officers and men.”

Bryant McClenaghan’s In Memoriam, in the July 1915 edition:

I regret to say that Bryant was killed yesterday in an attack we made on the German trenches…. he was rallying some men at the time, when he was shot through the heart. I placed him in a trench, hoping that the wound would not be fatal. The only words to me were, ‘Don’t mind me.’… When I saw him a quarter of an hour later he had died a very gallant death at the head of his Company, and the men are very sad to have lost him, as he was extremely popular among the men. I need hardly say how sorry the officers are. He was the cheeriest and most popular subaltern among us and he was my best friend in the regiment.

He died instantaneously; he got a bullet in his throat, and as he fell he shouted, ‘Go on boys.’ He was one of the best subalterns I ever had…I particularly noticed him leading his men in what was really a storm of shot and shell, and the wonder was how any of them came out of it alive.’ As a matter of fact every officer in the regiment was hit.

…There was a man ten yards behind him, wounded in the stomach, and your son turned round and shouted, ‘For God’s sake, man, don’t drink that water!’ and, as he turned his head forward again, he was shot in the middle of the forehead. He lived for eighteen hours and was never conscious again.


“Glorious! Glorious!" said Ferrers, as they staggered out into the cool night air. “A war is what we want. It will wake us up from sleeping; stir us into life; inflame our literature. There's a real chance now of sweeping away the old outworn traditions. In a great fire they will all be burnt. Then we can build afresh. I wish I could go and fight. […] This war is going to save England and everything! Glorious!”

I showed Dick the telegram when I returned. I had seen Stephen when he was on leave in the spring, and he had written to me only a week ago. Reading the Roll of Honour in the daily paper wasn’t the same thing as this. Looking at Dick’s blank face I became aware that he would never see Stephen now, and the meaning of the telegram became clear to me.

The deadliest solvent of your exalted hatreds is laughter. And you can never wholly suppress laughter between two crowds of millions of men standing within earshot of each other along a line of hundreds of miles.

Montague is also the origin of the old soldier Ellwood sees who dyed his white hair black in order to enlist. Montague was forty-seven in 1914. Despite disapproving of the war, he felt a moral obligation to enlist.

You bragged how once in a savage mood
Your men butchered some Saxon prisoners, that was good.
I trust you felt no pity as they stood
Patient and cowed and scared as prisoners should.

How did you kill them? Speak now, don’t be shy,
You know I love to hear how Germans die
Downstairs in dug-outs, ‘Camerad!’ they cry;
And squeal like stoats when bombs begin to fly.

I’m proud of you; perhaps you’ll feel as brave
Alone in no-man’s land when no one can shield you from the horror of the night.
There’s blood upon your hands
Now go out and fight.

I hope those Huns will haunt you with their screams
And make you gulp their blood in ghoulish dreams.
You’re great at murder; tell me, can you fight?

I have come to tell you a terrible fact. Only one out of ten of you girls can ever hope to marry. This is not a guess of mine. It is a statistical fact. Nearly all the men who might have married you have been killed. You will have to make your way in the world as best you can. The war has made more openings for women than there were before. But there will still be a lot of prejudice. You will have to fight. You will have to struggle.

It is something of an anachronism to insert this before the Battle of the Somme, which is when people began to understand the scale of the attrition. The war left over a million “Surplus Women” who never married. Virginia Nicholson explores this phenomenon in her fascinating book, Singled Out: How Two Million British Women Survived Without Men after the First World War (2008).

Any fool could foresee what happened when troops got bunched up as they left their trench for a daylight attack; and I knew that, in spite of obstinate indentations to the source of supplies, we hadn’t got a decent pair of wire-cutters in the Battalion. (Memoirs of an Infantry Officer)

…Are you there? . . .
Yes . . . and the War won't end for at least two years;
But we've got stacks of men. . . . I'm blind with tears,
Staring into the dark. Cheero!
I wish they'd killed you in a decent show.

[Sassoon said] ‘War has made me. I think I am a man now as well as a poet. You have said the things well enough. Now let us nevermore say another word of whatever little may be good in war for the individual who has a heart to be steeled.’

I remember I nodded, for further acquaintance with war inclines me to his opinion.

‘Let no one ever,’ he continued, ‘from henceforth say a word in any way countenancing war. It is dangerous even to speak of how here and there the individual may gain some hardship of soul by it. For war is hell and those who institute it are criminals. Were there anything to say for it, it should not be said for its spiritual disasters far outweigh any of its advantages.’

Historical license:

← Back to In Memoriam